Exactly what I told him,

bad implementation, better be safe than sorry.

We care about the game, that's why we suggest you remove it. It's not healthy for the game.

Agree... and encoraging forum participating in this way most like will only make it worse. 

Not to be blunt, but why was this marked as "Implemented" if it wasn't implemented?
By the looks of it, forum respect is still tied to battle stats.

The achievement has been removed as requested. I had hoped for the best but you guys were right.

Another massive w from you, Diablo!

the idea was interesting but you listened to the community instead of being stubborn. Thank you!